Reply to peer reviewers with AI
Break each review into individual concerns and pair your answers with evidence. Keep the reviewer’s words, your reply and the proposed manuscript changes distinct.
Reply to peer reviewers with AI when one paragraph of feedback calls for several different answers. A referee might question a comparison, ask for a missing result and flag an unclear caption in the same comment. The rebuttal-writing skill separates those concerns so that a quick caption fix does not obscure a substantive question about the evidence.
The agent helps build a worksheet before drafting a full reply. For each point, it can record your position, the supporting result, the limits of the claim and a specific revision. An experiment under discussion stays marked as proposed. Only completed and verified work can be presented as new evidence in the response.
What it does
- Map each reviewer comment to a distinct answer.
- Group a shared concern across several reviews.
- Identify a claim that needs a narrower scope.
- Name the exact caption, table or sentence to amend.
- Cut repetitive wording to meet the venue’s length limit.
Install and use
- Install the skill in a text-capable agent and supply only review materials you are authorised to share, along with the venue rules and word limit.
- Ask, “Split this comment into its separate concerns and identify which ones our existing figures answer.”
- Check the proposed replies against the manuscript, including all numerical claims and promised revisions.
FAQ
Source
Made by Max Simchowitz. Original skill: rebuttal-writing, published on GitHub under the MIT licence.
View on GitHub