All products

Review product decision reasoning with AI

Examine the evidence, alternatives and reversibility behind a product choice

Review product decision reasoning with AI by asking what supported the choice when it was made. The pm-decision-quality-audit skill examines a decision memo or retrospective without treating a fortunate outcome as proof of sound reasoning. It looks for missing alternatives, unsupported confidence, sunk-cost arguments and a mismatch between deliberation and reversibility.

Findings include a severity, the relevant principle and a concrete fix, ending with three priorities. Review effort should match the cost of being wrong: a small reversible choice does not need the ceremony of an expensive commitment. This evaluates a documented rationale and process, not someone’s personality, and cannot validate the underlying evidence automatically.

What it does

  • Separate reasoning from later outcomes
  • Check alternatives and rejected options
  • Assess the cost of reversing a choice
  • Expose assumptions and confidence claims
  • Challenge arguments based on sunk costs
  • Prioritise changes that matter to the decision

Install and use

  1. Use the instruction file and licence in a compatible text assistant through the maker’s documented prompt route. Supply the rationale and evidence known at the time; the host processes those materials.
  2. For example: “Review the reasoning behind this tool purchase. Use only evidence available then, and identify what could change the choice.”
  3. State the stakes, reversibility and whether the decision is proposed or already made. Ask for text-specific findings and practical countermeasures rather than unsupported labels.
  4. Review the three priorities with the decision owner. Record assumptions and revisit triggers; other audits are separate optional lenses, not prerequisites for this direct review.

FAQ

Source

Made by Uxcel Lab. Original skill: pm-decision-quality-audit, published on GitHub under the MIT licence.

View on GitHub