Record gaps between a paper and Lean with AI
Write a traceable note when a formal declaration and its cited mathematical source disagree or appear to require different hypotheses.
Record gaps between a paper and Lean with AI when a formalisation proves less, more or something slightly different from the statement it cites. The paper-gap-notes skill helps an agent prepare a standalone mathematical note with a precise source location, affected declarations and an evidence-based classification of the difference.
For instance, a proof in the project may require a nonzero parameter while the printed statement appears unrestricted. The condition may be implicit earlier in the paper, a limitation of the current proof or an actual gap. The note can preserve that question while the team investigates, without presenting suspicion as a published correction.
What it does
- Compare the hypotheses and conclusion of two statements.
- Distinguish notation changes from restrictions on scope.
- Identify declarations that rely on an additional assumption.
- Record a genuinely unresolved step with its supporting evidence.
- Keep the blueprint and formal source aligned after a correction.
Install and use
- Use a file-capable agent with the authorised source passage and Lean project. A local TeX setup is needed only to compile the optional note template.
- Ask it to describe the specific mismatch and mark any proposed explanation that lacks evidence.
- Have someone familiar with the mathematics check the note and the affected declaration before changing its status.
FAQ
Source
Made by Texra (texra-ai). Original skill: paper-gap-notes, published on GitHub under the MIT licence.
View on GitHub