All products

Respond to peer review with AI

Track each reviewer request alongside the change you made. Give the editor a clear account of completed revisions, unresolved points and evidence-based disagreements.

Respond to peer review with AI by separating the reviewer’s questions before composing the letter. One paragraph may challenge the sampling method and the readability of a figure. Revising the method answers only half the comment, even if the reply sounds complete.

The rebuttal-and-response-to-reviewers guide helps organise an author response around evidence and verifiable changes. A reader should be able to open the revised manuscript at the cited location and see what happened. If the authors disagree, a precise account of the issue and its limits is more informative than an emphatic assurance.

What it does

  • Break a long comment into distinct requests
  • Map an answer to a section, page or figure
  • Distinguish completed revisions from pending work
  • Explain a disagreement using evidence already available
  • Prioritise points under a conference response limit

Install and use

  1. Use an authorised writing environment with the review comments, the actual revised text and the venue’s current response rules. Protect confidential manuscripts and referee reports according to the relevant policy.
  2. Ask, “Split this comment into its method and figure requests. The method was revised in section two. Flag the figure as pending and do not claim it has changed.”
  3. Compare the response with the final manuscript. Check quotations and page numbers after any layout changes.

FAQ

Source

Made by Kalaris Labs (Sayan Chowdhury). Original skill: rebuttal-and-response-to-reviewers, published on GitHub under the MIT licence.

View on GitHub