All products

Plan a manuscript review with AI

Decide what an evidence reader, methods reader, argument reader and subject expert should each check before you send out a manuscript.

Plan a manuscript review with AI if everyone who reads your draft comes back with comments on the same opening paragraph. The manuscript-revision skill explains how to give four readers different jobs. One checks evidence against claims. Another looks for gaps in the method. The other two follow the argument and assess what a specialist would expect the paper to acknowledge.

A reader can flag a table whose figures contradict the discussion without rewriting either section. The author then weighs that finding alongside the other reports. This guide explains the division of labour, why the readers should see the rendered draft, and when another round has a purpose. An accompanying skill runs the actual review cycle.

What it does

  • Prepare different briefs for the evidence, method, argument and expert readers.
  • Ask which limitations the methods reader should look for.
  • Distinguish a missing source from a gap in the paper’s argument.
  • Work through competing comments before assigning a revision.
  • Decide whether any major objections still justify a fresh reading.

Install and use

  1. Install the skill in your agent. Discussing a review plan needs no research account or project setup.
  2. Describe your draft and ask, “Which reader should decide whether the conclusion goes beyond the results?”
  3. Use the responsibilities and stopping rule to agree how the team will handle the next round.

FAQ

Source

Made by Mikko Rönkkö. Original skill: manuscript-revision, published on GitHub under the MIT licence.

View on GitHub